We all have differing opinions about whether a beginner should start with bouldering or top rope. Why? Because “difficult” does not mean the same thing to everyone. So, bouldering vs top rope – how do you know where to start?
First, we need to discuss the main differences between these two sports. When you know what each activity involves, the decision about where to start will come quickly to you. Stick around!
Bouldering is a sport that involves climbing boulders or artificial rock walls without using a harness or rope.
With top-rope climbing, the climber is fastened to an anchored rope. In this sport, the cord is usually docked at the top or end of the climbing route, and climbers use the rope to progress faster. There is often a belayer in top-rope climbing that pulls the rope as the climber moves up. Even if you fall, you will not need to fall very far.
The most apparent difference between top-rope climbing and bouldering is the presence of an anchored rope or a harness in top-rope climbing. Bouldering does not have either of both things. This is one of the reasons why a lot of new climbers are anxious about falling when bouldering.
With top-roping, the chances of falling far are not very high. Even if you fall, it would likely be a shortfall, and you could then continue with your climb.
Bouldering is usually done at lower heights than top-roping. This is yet another difference between the two sports. Some people say they feel much safer top-roping because of the anchor; others feel more comfortable bouldering because the heights are not as high.
Generally, bouldering tests your power, while top-roping requires more endurance. Tope rope grades are fixed based on the most challenging move you’ll do on the route. With bouldering, you will encounter multiple complex movements successively that could wear you out pretty quickly.
Bouldering is graded based on how much of a challenge it would be for you (the climber) physically.
Bouldering routes are graded using the V-Scale, while top rope routes are graded with the YDS scale. The V-Scale starts from V0 and currently does not have any top-level difficulty. As for the YDS scale, it runs from 5.0 to 5.15d.
While 5.0 is the most manageable top rope route grade, it is not equivalent to a V0. For example, a V0 bouldering route grade would be equivalent to a 5.9 top rope route grade.
We would say bouldering is more challenging than top-roping. This is for several reasons. First is the grading. Bouldering starts at a much more difficult grade than top rope grades.
With top-roping, you can always pause or lean on the rope if you start to feel tired. Bouldering does not offer that. The harness’s absence is also why you fall harder when you lose grip bouldering than with top rope.
As a beginner, it is easier to think that bouldering is more accessible because bouldering routes are generally shorter than top-rope routes. However, bouldering requires a lot more skill and strength than top-roping. The most accessible bouldering grades and intermediate top rope routes are often on the same difficulty level.
We can’t say if bouldering is better than top-roping because they have several differences. If you are interested in building your power and learning many more skills, bouldering helps with that. On the other hand, it requires more technique than top-roping. Also, bouldering might be very daunting for you if you fear the possibility of a long fall. There’s no rope to hold on to.
There is also the angle where you would need to place a lot of trust in the belayer when top-roping, but that would not be the case with bouldering as there is no rope or belayer.
Top-roping might be pretty scary for you if you are scared of heights because of the routes. On the other hand, bouldering would not be as intimidating because even though it is difficult, the courses are not as high.
Bouldering is a form of climbing. Bouldering is safer than rock climbing, but it depends on your personal risk assessment. You might feel differently. It is common to sustain bouldering injuries, but it is never something significant. With rock climbing, injuries are rare but usually quite severe. It is safer because you know that even if you do get hurt bouldering, it will probably be something relatively minor.
Top rope climbing is probably one of the safest forms of climbing. The heights can sometimes be scary, but the minimal risk is involved when you have the right equipment and a competent belayer. Even when you fall, you won’t fall very far. Also, you can always take a break to rest on the rope when you’re tired. Then, you would not need to worry about losing grip and falling to the ground.
So, here’s a quick summary before you go…
Top-roping will be the easier option if you are starting your climbing journey. Bouldering might look more accessible, but it requires much more technique, and you might fall many times while climbing.
While top-roping and bouldering are both forms of climbing, they have significant differences. There is no rope or anchor to help with your climb with bouldering. There is also a belayer present during top roping that helps ensure that even when you fall, you do not fall very far.
You might get a few injuries while bouldering, but it likely won’t be serious. For safe top-roping, ensure you have the right equipment and a proper belayer.
Lastly, whichever sport you go for, have fun. The nervousness is normal, and you’ll definitely get the hang of it. All it takes is lots and lots of practice!